Excuse Me, But You're Doing It Wrong....7 (no- 9!) Reasons NOT To Correct Your Partner in Aikido

By -
In Aikido practice, I often see a less experienced student "correct" an experienced student. I'm sure these people genuinely feel they're offering something of value. But it's inappropriate, incorrect and detrimental to your own progress to correct people who've been practicing longer than you.

A while ago someone asked Cecelia Ricciotti (7th dan), "What do I do if I'm working with someone who has more experience, and they just plain out-and-out are doing it wrong?" "Well," she said, "You have to make a decision: Do you want to take on the role of teacher? Or do you want to continue to be a student?"

7 Reasons Not To Correct Your (More Experienced) Partner In Aikido
  • Respecting each other is one of the most important parts of our practice. You demonstrate respect for someone who has more training than you by listening to what they have to teach you. Especially if you disagree with them, it's a great opportunity to practice finding a way to respect where they are coming from.
  • You may think you "know" something that your partner doesn't know. But you will actually learn more by listening and watching than by talking. This has been my experience many, many times.
  • We all have a habit of talking too much during our practice. Practice not talking. Listen with your ears and your body. Maybe your partner will, too. 
  • Your partner is likely to react negatively to a "suggestion" from someone with less experience. They may avoid working with you in future. They may even mention their experience to others. Is that what you want?
  • A more experienced partner may want to go slowly, or want you to resist less, or may hesitate and ask you to do something again. This doesn't mean they don't know what to do. They may be exploring a nuance in the technique, or some other important thought. If you're quiet, you may get the benefit of this idea once they work it out!  
  • Sometimes your partner actually is wrong. They may even be doing the wrong technique. It happens. So what? You may learn something even though you're doing the "wrong" thing. Maybe all you'll learn is that you have the ability to choose to say nothing.
  • If you're a black belt and you're working with another black belt you don't know, you may not know which of you has more experience. How lovely! You can practice together without one of you having to take on the role of teacher. 
Curbing my desire to correct others who are more experienced is not about getting hung up on rank. It's about practicing humility. I want to learn Kokikai Aikido. Especially since I do teach aikido students, I have to make sure I "continue to be a student" whenever I can. When I do, it makes it easier to listen and easier to learn.

Post script: Cecelia kindly added the following (bringing the total to nine!):

  • Things that people work out for themselves have more value than things that are told or given to them. There's no harm in allowing a partner figure out what's wrong for themselves. 
  • Practicing with someone silently is waaaaay more fun that discussing the technique.
Thanks, Cecelia, as always, for your advice!






Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to Make a "Rush" Woven Seat Chair Using Old Jeans (or Fabric Scraps)

By -
Image
I used the technique for weaving a rush chair seat to make a chair seat using old jeans. The antique ladderback chair is just the right height for me to practice my Québécois button accordion. Fabric Choice Although at first I considered using t-shirt strips (also called tarn), I decided to jeans because denim is stronger and not stretchy. I had some old heavy linen fabric that would have done the trick, too, but I didn't have enough for the whole chair with either linen or jeans. I decided not to mix them, at least not for my first chair. I was advised, (correctly!) by other crafters, that all I had to do was out the word out, and I’d get donations. I sent out 4 emails and literally went shopping and there were two pairs of jeans on my doorstep. I had five more pairs by the weekend. (Now I need another chair!) Some Pointers Before I describe the process, here are some pointers. I don't recommend doing this with a stretchy fabric. Therefore, if you use jeans, avo...
Read more

Keep One Point

By -
Image
I've been slowly but surely writing of a series posts devoted to each of the  four basic principles of Kokikai Aikido . One of these is Keep One Point to Develop Calmness. We spend about 90 minutes in each aikido class, and most students practice once or twice a week - only a small proportion of the of hours we are awake each week. It may be plenty of time to spend doing a demanding physical exercise, but we need to spend more time working on the underlying principles for them to become second nature in our bodies. Fortunately, all of the basic principles are easily practiced at any time, not just in class. We can easily practice finding and keeping One Point while off the mat, and test the results when we're back on the mat. What Is One Point? One Point is a concept closely related to your center of balance. Centuries ago martial artists discovered that if the mind is focused on keeping this point low, one becomes stronger and harder to move. In Kokikai, we first...
Read more

What is Ki?

By -
Image
The concept of Ki , or lifeforce, exists in many cultures. In Chinese it's Chi or Qi , in Sanskrit,  Prana . In western culture, while we may say someone has a soul that is distinct from their physical body, the soul is connected to the individual.  Ki, as it is understood in Japanese culture, is a universal force that permeates everything. Individuals may manifest more or less ki, but it is a connecting force between everyone and everything. In Japan, ki is an everyday concept that's found in many common phrases . For example the phrase "O  ki o tsuke te," which means "take care," literally means, "apply ki ."   "O genki desu?" the most common way to say "How are you?" means, literally, "Do you have ki ?"   "Ii k imochi," a phrase heard often, particularly in popular songs, means "(What a) good feeling." "Ii" means "good" and "kimochi" literally means having, o...
Read more